Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Socially Awkward: "Compliments" That Make Me Uncomfortable

Either I am really good at feeling uncomfortable (very possible), or people are good at making comments that steer me that direction.   It doesn't really matter which is the case.   I think the real problem is that we as women are notorious for playing the comparison game.  And I'm not sure which is worse - comparing yourself to others and feeling like you don't measure up, or receiving comments that clearly reveal others are comparing themselves to you and feel that they are not measuring up.

Thankfully, I was raised with boys.  Though I have five sisters and six brothers, as the second oldest my childhood mostly centered around my older brother and my two immediately younger brothers.  (I was not blessed with my first wonderful sister until I was eight.)  I also consider myself extremely blessed to have also been home schooled through third grade.  Formative years, I tell you.  I think that those two things combined kept me pretty ignorant to the female curse of comparing every aspect of your life with that of other females.  Likewise, I also lack the ability to properly respond to women that constantly make such comparisons out loud.   Because I generally don't play the game, I never really learned the rules.  I think I'm beginning to figure it out though.  I believe it goes something like this:

Person A compliments person B in a wistful, "I wish I was like you" sort of fashion. 

Person B responds in denial of the compliment and flips the compliment around in order to build up Person A, since apparently Person A is in need of affirmation in that particular area.

Example:

Person A: "Oh you are such a wonderful cook!  I wish I was good in the kitchen (wistful tone)."
Person B: "Are you kidding me!?  I am just mediocre in the kitchen.  YOU, on the other hand, are an awesome cook.  Remember that _______ you made the other day?  I have never been successful at it."
Person A: (Responds, blah blah blah...on and on it goes.) 

Women talk to each other like this, call it a friendship, and expect men to interpret this nonsense when we throw it at them?!  (Poor guys.)
Jealousy, you are an ugly beast.  When most people think of jealousy, they picture the person who portrays resentment, but what about those who are the target of envy? 

I have a problem.  And I am going to try to say this without sounding completely conceited.  (I have been tremendously blessed in my life.  I don't deny that).  However, it seems that by perhaps some fault of my own, some people have developed quite a terrible misconception that I "have it all together," that I am pretty nearly perfect.   Huh?  I don't try to give anyone a false impression.  I am as human as the next person.  As I have caught onto this trend over the past few years, it has begun to make me feel extremely awkward around some folks.  Seriously, nothing has been more of an annoying burden in my adult life than people thinking that I am better than I am.  It is utterly ridiculous and just wrong.  It causes some women to feel as though they cannot be themselves in my presence, which both pains and confuses me.  I wish I knew what I was doing to cause this.  In fact, I sometimes tell self-incriminating stories and point out my faults all too easily in some social circles just to make sure that I don't mislead anyone.  Silly, right? 

However, it has not been successful, and I still receive lots of envious statements loosely disguised as compliments about my talents, parenting, body, marriage, intelligence, etc.  And then it hit me: I'm not fooling anyone.  They can see right through my stories of breaking dishes because I'm clumsy, and burning my neck with a curling iron during a morning rush.  They don't really care that I'm deaf in one ear, or that I can be as blunt and judgemental as the worst of humans.  It doesn't matter that I'm a housewife who doesn't like to cook.  You see, no one is actually as envious of my talents, parenting, body, marriage, intelligence, as it seems.

It's my confidence that they want.  When you know you're loved and accepted and made exactly, perfectly the way the Lord wanted you - and I mean really know it to the point that it permeates your heart and  affects your day-to-day choices -  why wouldn't you be confident in yourself?  I know who I am, I know what I want...and lately I'm realizing that not everyone can say that.    

I am also the sort of person that rarely sees any point in blubbering about all the things I dislike about myself or my life, so I suppose you won't hear the other side from me very often.  I just generally don't like to complain about my life, plain and simple.  Unless of course it's good material for humor.  

But just in case this blog - which I keep largely as a record for our family, particularly our children - aids in any misrepresentation of its author, I aim to set the record straight.   For the next week, I will only write negative posts about all things I hate about myself.

Or not

However, I will be sharing some real life "things I struggle with" posts in the near future.  (I would say this week, except that I'm going to be a road trip taking, family hosting, busy sort of lady for the next week-ish.  We will see.)

And in the meantime, if you're a person who is jealous of my moderate creativity, then please come help me organize my house so you can see the flip side (like how we "creative types" often struggle with organizational skills).  But whatever you do, don't compliment me on my creativity and then in the same breath say how much you wish you were creative.  How about you be you and I'll be me, and we'll both be happy with our own unique set of strengths.

I guess we'll take the accompanying weaknesses too. ;-)

7 comments:

LeAnna said...

Great post! I wish I could blog like you...
Sorry, I couldn't resist. :P

Girl, I totally get this. I have been in situations like you mentioned numerous times, and it has ruined a few good friendships. There is nothing more discouraging than friendships that are constantly trying to match skills (or lack thereof!). I just wish women would compare less and love more. We are all capable of confidence in Christ - and anything less is really just forms of idolatry! Not to say I have it all figured out, or never struggle with anything - but I do my best to choose contentment, because life is short and God sees it fit for me to be where I am, and that is an honor.

No, really! This is a great post.

Emily Delster said...

Ditto to LeAnna! I have experienced this and even (hangs head in shame) been a contributor to the madness from time to time. Comparison can be tempting in some situations, but what a great reminder of why it is so silly and all around unhealthy.

I never really know what to say to the "I am so jealous of your ____" comments (or some resemblance of that) that make you feel like you have to downplay the good things happening or your accomplishments. It's annoying! And it's not actually a compliment, like you said. It's awkward.

I really liked this post :)

Cami Jo said...

I loved this post too! I think maybe we should get together sometime. I think we'd get along quite well!

I was with a some girls tonight to watch a movie and it wasn't one
I loved or really even liked. It had lots of "beatiful" girls dancing and stuff, and the first thing out of one of the girls mouth when the credits came up was, "Oh....that makes me wish I was as skinny as her, or could dance like that". SO dumb! I love how you said, Jealousy is a beast! We are ALL beautiful. All with flaws. And all exactly the way we need to be. Good reminder Amelia! Thanks!

Anonymous said...

Hey! Found your blog through a link on Emily D's, and really enjoy reading.

And while I understand where you are coming from with this post I wanted to offer another perspective. : )

Women do have a tendency to put themselves down. I would say it is more about how they were raised then just being women though. People from dysfunctional families are especially prone to equating deeds with self worth. It's a sad symptom of being verbally abused. It takes so much to even to get to the point of 'I am loved because I am, not because of what I do'.

Obviously this doesn't mean every woman who compliments you while putting herself down has had a difficult childhood, but it's something to consider. You could say, 'thank you for the compliment! You are really great at _____" and if she continues to do that, and you feel comfortable enough, you could say, "I notice how hard you are on yourself, do you want to talk about how you are feeling?"

If someone has been made to feel like nothing in her formative years by the people who are suppose to love her unconditionally it is a gripping pain of not being good enough. It's so wonderful that you can show other women what it is like to surrender to the love of Christ.

Thanks for the amazing blogs!

-Emily Floyd

Heidi said...

Thank you. I really needed to hear this...

Anonymous said...

Great post! May I offer a response too?
Isn't it wonderful that we are all part of the body of Christ? Isn't it wonderful that some of us are creative, some of us are especially gifted with special needs children, some of us are awesome cooks, awesome volunteers, givers, doers, hospitable, care givers, financial stewards, organized and the list goes on.
For me, comments like "you have the perfect life" cause me to think "IF YOU ONLY KNEW!"
No one has a "perfect life". We all have moments of wonderful and many moments of mundane or "I wish I could fast forward to tomorrow." We are all wonderfully made with the right talents. It's the BODY that make us whole. I'm thankful that I am not masters of all attributes. I'm thankful for the opportunities where I can do what I do best everyday. TODAY, I will give thanks for day the Lord has made. I WILL rejoice and be glad in it. Thank you ladies for sharing your talents with all of us. We may envy your talents. Let's just be thankful for our own talents and the opportunity to share them with others. PTL.

Amelia said...

@LeAnna, ha ha ha ha! That was pretty funny. Thanks for your comment. You are right, choosing contentment is soo key.

@Emily D, I think we are all contributors at times! I think some just verbalize it more often than others. I would be lying if I said I didn't struggle with comparison thoughts too. The key is turning it over to God and asking Him for contentment every day. I think you are doing that. Yes, I think that is what bothers me the most about it. I don't want to feel as though I need to downplay or hide the good things in my life in order to safeguard the feelings of everyone and their mom. I do not need to mindlessly brag - I should stay humble - but I should be able to just be me.

@Cami, Thanks! I think we would get along well too. :-)

@Emily Floyd, thanks for challenging my thinking in a respectful way. I definitely could use some improvements in many areas of my life, one of them certainly being in the area of compassion and understanding the "need behind the deed." You have given me something to think about in an area where I tend to have a "sin is sin" attitude.

Everyone else, thanks for your comments!